Turn Your Collection Into Cash — or Something New.

For many desirable cards and collectibles, our cash offers typically range from approximately 50–80% of current market value.

Offers may be higher or lower depending on the item. We consider factors such as condition, rarity, current demand, recent comparable sales, how quickly an item typically sells, the size of the collection and our current inventory.

Market value does not necessarily represent what an item can be sold for immediately, so every offer is evaluated individually.

The easiest way to sell or trade is to bring your items to Neo Collector in downtown Cleveland.

Bring in your cards or collectibles and we’ll take a look. There’s no obligation to accept our offer.

For larger or higher-value collections, we recommend contacting us before coming in so we can make sure we have enough time to properly evaluate everything.

You don’t have to be in Cleveland to sell to Neo Collector.

Email us at hello@neocollectorshop.com with the subject line “Sell / Trade” and include:

For larger collections, feel free to include a spreadsheet, inventory list or additional photos.

We’ll review your submission and let you know if we’re interested. If we are, we’ll discuss the next steps with you.